|
Down to the Sea
By: Bruce Henderson
(368 pages: photos, maps)
Reviewer: Bernie
Ditter
Overall
Rating: Four Stars--Highly recommended. An excellent book.
One week before
Christmas in 1944 the third
fleet was directed into the path
of a typhoon resulting in damage
to 28 ships, the loss of three
ships, 146 aircraft and nearly
800 lives. On January 3rd of
1945, a scant 16 days later, a
court of inquiry announced its
finding of fact, opinion and
recommendations.
Not since "The
Last Stand of the Tin Can
Sailors" by James D. Hornfischer
has an author captured a moment
in naval history so well. This
is a must read for anyone who
ever served at sea whether on a
destroyer or any other ship of
the fleet.
Prodigious
research on the part of the
author provides an almost hourly
account of this disaster from
its earliest warning signs
(which were ignored by the
highest authority) to the last
minutes at sea by many of the
survivors. Readers will either
be angered by the apparent lack
of judgment on the part of those
responsible for the safety of
the fleet or rationalize the
situation as the members of the
court of inquiry did. Was this a
classic example of situational
ethics? In wartime does the
axiom -- for the greater good --
take on a different meaning?
This book
presents an awkward dilemma as
the villain in this story is us.
It is difficult to ascribe the
loss of lives and the sheer
destruction of so many fighting
machines to human error.
Perhaps the
failures of those in command
serve to enlarge the heroics by
those who are commanded. The
selfless actions of many in
their efforts to save the lives
of their shipmates can only be
marveled at. The sobriquet "The
Greatest Generation" is so
descriptive of the men of that
time that I doubt it will ever
become tiresome to hear.
Bruce Henderson
has produced a book that should
sit proudly in the bookcase of
any American. Get one for your
favorite sailor. |