|
South Pacific Destroyer: The
Battle for the Solomons from
Savo Island to Vella Gulf
By
Russell Sydnor Crenshaw, Jr.
(304 pages, photos, drawings, maps)
Reviewer: Terry Miller
Overall Rating:
Four Stars: Highly recommended. An excellent book.
Much
has been written about the
United States Navy’s operations
during the WWII battles for the
Solomon Islands but none to
surpass the in-depth analysis
that Captain Crenshaw who was
executive officer in one of the
destroyers that took part in
many if not most of these
battles. Crenshaw, then a
22-year old gunnery
officer-turned XO was in a
position to oversee every aspect
of the operation of USS MAURY
(DD-401) from his battle station
in the newly created Combat
Information Center and he uses
those experiences to tell the
stories of destroyer operations
in 1943, whether the routine or
the extreme stress of battle.
More
importantly, Crenshaw exposes
some major flaws in U.S. Naval
thinking of the time, pointing
out the arrogance which allowed
us to naïvely believe anything
we made was inherently superior
to that made by an enemy. This
was most especially true of
torpedoes and five- and six-inch
naval artillery where the lack
of funding and testing could not
be overcome in the fleet by
training and maintenance.
He
shows us the immediate effects
of the new destroyer doctrine,
written and implemented by then
Commander Arleigh Burke and put
into action by his replacement
as ComDesDiv 12, Commander
Frederick Moosbrugger. The
success of utilizing destroyers
independent of larger warships
can’t be taken lightly. It had
never been done before and
destroyers had previously been
limited to a role as adjuncts to
cruiser warfare, then thought to
be the major surface-engagement
fighting force. Crenshaw reviews
for the reader how thinking
changed.
He
also discusses the creation of
the notion of the Combat
Information Center or CIC during
the Solomons Campaign and how it
related to this new destroyer
doctrine.
Whether read for
its historical significance or
for pleasure, South Pacific
Destroyer is sure to please
everyone interested in
destroyers, the Pacific War, or
naval history.Availability:
Tin Can Sailors Ship's Store
|